The Debate over Mystical Monism in the 17th Century: the ‘Unity of Existence’ and Non-Muslims in the Ottoman and Mughal Empires

This paper explores the Sufi philosophy known as the “Unity of Being”(waḥdat al-wujūd) in the early modern Ottoman and Mughal Empires. In the 17th century, debates surrounding this system of thought can tell us much about Sufism as well as the history of empire, changing religious demographics, and contests over political and religious authority. This study examines  adherents to the doctrine of waḥdat al-wujūd like Şeyh Bedreddin (d.1421 c.e.), Mughal prince Dārā Shikūh (d. 1659 c.e.), and ‘Abd al-Ghanī Nābulusī  (d.1731 c.e.) against Aḥmad Sirhindī’s (d. 1624 c.e.) intervention rejecting this doctrine. By exploring these case studies it becomes apparent that anxieties over the demarcation between Islam and non-Muslim religions are at the crux of what makes this philosophy so controversial, and that its defenders attempt to navigate a course between the particulars of Islam and the universalizing worldview of mystical monism.